Username:   Password:   
   
   autoracing Forum
Index  FAQ  Search  Memberlist  Usergroups  Profile  Register
 Log in to check your private messages
Regan Smith won and Tony Stewart is in victory lane
  Post new topic   Reply to topic x-autoracing-x.com Forum Index » General autoracing Forum     
Message
Driver     Reply with quote
l remember it being legal on the last lap and Tony Stewart forced him down there, Regan won...
dwi     Reply with quote
im not so sure regan faked him and stewert came back to his spot then smith went down the line and passed stewert to the line

yes nascar should keep the rule for all the laps or none of them

thank you stinky


i APOLOGIZE IF LAST YEAR IN THE TRUCK RACE THEY ALLOWED TODD BODINE TO PASS UNDER THE YELLOW LINE THEN THEY SHOULD GIVE THE WIN TO REGAN SMITH
Gadget     Reply with quote
Well why should it be with the last lap. ANd not the other laps.
They should get rid of it altogether.
Drunk     Reply with quote
ya he should have won, the rule is if you are forced down there it is a legal pass, Regan won, congrats to him, nascar should be ashamed
Coach     Reply with quote
l dont know what the rule is for the last lap, l actually think that it was Tony that won. Because of the rule that you arent allowed to pass under the yellow line. Tony let him back up onto the track and Regan should have gone behind Tony, but he didnt.
Kim     Reply with quote
l agree with M.Pepper, but the rules are rules
Lostyo     Reply with quote
Yes, Regan should be in victory lane. l also thought is was anything goes on the last lap. But congrats to him and Paul Menard for their amazing and well deserved finishes!!!
Bobyer     Reply with quote
You're right, Mr. President. Smith won that race. l am so disgusted l can not see straight.
Do not get me wrong - l like Smoke. But NASCAR needs to stop using their Etch-A-Sketch for a rule book. : (
Kickshaw     Reply with quote
That is the benefits of a #2 pencil. They can change the rules anytime they want to. But l had never heard the rule before. It just seems like every day it is a new rule the just pops up out of nowhere.

Congrats Tony Stewart fans

Ragan won it though. Stewart was blocking and forced Ragan down below the line. The replay shows Ragan had his front fender beside Tony Stewart is rear quarter panel.
Lemon     Reply with quote
l am a ''smoke'' fan but trust me that was a weird one. l think DJ summed it up but l was busy celebrating. As usual a rule that people never had an issue with is now a farce for those who is driver did not win or do not like Tony. Yay!
couzo     Reply with quote
That is the first time l remember someone crossing the finish line 1st place only for the win to be given to 2nd right after the race. l am wondering if Smith was leading, and Stewart went to the inside, if NASCAR would have gave Smith the win.

l would have been happy to see either win, but it should be given to whoever crosses the finish line in the lead.
Callaway     Reply with quote
That was a load of ******* BS. During the truck race yesterday the announcers clearly stated that you are allowed to go below the yellow line on the last lap or if you are forced down there. Smith had both of those. But once again Nascar screws another driver out of a victory.. Good job to Regan, he gave it everything he had.
Que     Reply with quote
never legal.time and time again we've seen someone having to give spots up because they passed beneath the yellow line. Why should this be any different???

Yeah l was routing for Tony..but if it were the other way around l would have felt the same way.

Still.this has to be a big shot in the arm for DEI.
Happy     Reply with quote
Regan got forced down below and made the pass, you're not the only one who thought that was legal. They said NASCAR has not placed Regan. Hopefully they will decide he is the winner. They better, because he won that race.
krystal     Reply with quote
You can go below the line, even if forced down there, but you CANNOT IMPROVE YOUR POSITION.

That has always been the rule, last lap or not.

But hey, he gave it a shot and it made for a heck of a finish.
Koenig     Reply with quote
Although l was surprised they gave the win to Stewart, what Tom P says is correct, l believe. You are allowed below the yellow line, but not to improve your position.
laser     Reply with quote
l have 2 stewart fans in my house right now, and they agree that regan should have won. l do not care what anyone says, regan won fair and square.

Congrats Regan!!!!
aeroz     Reply with quote
It is legal to go below the yellow line if forced down. It is not legal to gain position from it.
Controversial finish, to say the least.
Pink     Reply with quote
Yes, Regan Smith won the race! Damn it NASCAR, why do you always have to ruin the finishes. Regan got forced below the line and won. Plain and simple. The idiots who make up these rules might as well shoot themselves. Let the men race.

l hope they declare Smith the winner.
Outlaw     Reply with quote
l thought that it was never legal to improve your position when below the yellow line so l thought it was a fair call l know l am the minority in this but that is what l thought
ionus     Reply with quote
l picked Smoke to win in my fantasy pool, But l think Nascar needs to review this, Smoke forced Smith down there. l am still having a Carl Edwards meltdown here, l am ready to hire the AFLAC duck to go chew something off Carl Edwards for the mess he caused today.. l agree, Regan Smith should have won, but l think this needs to be reviewed unless JGR paid the officials off.

Go Dale Jr & Hms
Bad     Reply with quote
Regan Smith soooooooo won that race and yes the rule is on the last lap you get forced below the yellow line and advance your position you get to keep that position. But hey this is a NASCAR rule and we all know that it depends on the day, month, what the weather is doing as to what drivers the rule applies to. NASCAR you messed up bad today, very disappointed.
Maxim     Reply with quote
Rules are Rules. Just like it was OK and then some for Jr to pass the Pace Car for his win Michigan.

If Tony thought Regan was still a threat after he went under the yellow line, he would not have let him get ahead of him. Of that, l am sure.

Any other driver and this would not even be an issue.

l just wish he would have won it in his Home Depot 20
mg     Reply with quote
My DE l boys were top dogging it all day. Just so glad to see them up there. l feel so bad for Truex. l was really upset. Regan Smith has won his 1st race. l do not care what anyone else has to say that is negative. DE l was the team to Beat.
mule     Reply with quote
all l can say is goin to have to start watching **** indy cars
Denzil     Reply with quote
Agreed. To me it also looked like Smith just barely got back on track before passing Stewart so NASCAR is point was moot. Congrats to Regan Smith on his first career win even if it is not in the record books.
taber     Reply with quote
Usually, u could go under the yellow line, but could not pass unless u were forced down there. Also, the yellow line would be disregarded on the last lap in turn 4 & the tri-oval.

But this race, they said that u could not put the full width of a tire under the line. They also said that if u were forced down there, u had to fill a gap, even if it was behind you. If there was not one, u had to maintain ur position.

But what Regan did that was illegal, from my point of view, was to really use up the apron. If he had been right next to Stewart, he had a point, but he left a good gap of 2 or 3 feet. So NASCAR can say that he was forced down, but willfully used the apron to pass.
Mad     Reply with quote
regan won. l thought they said in the drivers meeting that anyone that forced someone below the yellow line was available to be black flagged for aggresive driving. l thought l saw it on speed but l could be wrong.
dwi     Reply with quote
Regan Smith won the race. l am done with NASCAR officially as of tonight.
Display posts from previous:   
  Post new topic   Reply to topic x-autoracing-x.com Forum Index » Generalautoracing Forum     

Lates Messages
Are you ready to ride the Carl Edwards bandwagon?
What did you think of the FIA analysis..?
What channel will the Daytona 500 be on in Aruba?
Which manufacturer make the best best engine and which team aligned with that manufacturer
(F1)If you could liken yourself to a driver, who would it be?
Nascar Nation...
WHATS A GOOD RACING SONG
Am I able to get an apprenticeship with a racing team
which current nascar driver would make a good host for his own talk show
What kind of driver are you?
Tony Eury Jr., right man for the job
which cup driver(s) will be the surprise story of 2009
What type of race is this?
Are any of you guys gonna take the piss test?
Is it just me, or do you have a hard time picking a favorite driver?
Which area is the best at the Bristol Tenn. Nascar Track for the night race
MSDS sheets for NASCAR Products
PLS an expert opinion needed!Do F-1 drivers have a alcoholic drink before racing?
Does Brad Keselowski ,,,?
Nascar Fans, Did I Miss Something in the Off Season
Anyone know where any car race track circuits are in Herefordshire
what is the best nascar race to go to (west coast)
Nascar Nation... did any of you get, or plan on getting the 2009 Nascarofficial preview and press guide
(Part 1)What are your thoughts on a new system for Cup?
(Part 2)What are your thoughts on a new system for Cup?
(Part 3)What are your thoughts on a new system for Cup?
Nascar fans will you watch the Super Bowl
Nascar Who is Tetsuo Fuchigami
Which state has the best racing
Chad McCumbee will he ever get a good ride? ?
John Andretti to be the driver for 4th EGR car, #34
Lewis Hamilton- Views
will kyle busch have a clean year this year and win the championship
Rolex 24 at Daytona vs 12 Hours of Sebring
Who were your favorite Nascar racers in the 70's
Nascar Nation...
Nascar Trivia! Can you name this driver
Gentlemen start your engines.
Is Formula 1 a predominantly male sport ?
Why do WRC cars have license plates?
Why do WRC rally cars have license plates?
i know bobby labonte will drive #96. but i dont read anywhere that he will drive in the 500?anyone know?
Let's build a Hollywood race car moovie
Can someone help me out here please
Have you ever been in yahoo's fantasy auto racing(nascar) Best %finish?
Have you ever seen MTV Cribs NASCAR style?
What is Dave Blaneys new Nascar number?
What ever happened to Dick Trickle?
Nascar Trivia! What sponsor do all these teams have in common?
did jimmie johnson shave yet
bathroom tubs forums , cable management forums , chopping block forums , countertop materials forums , coupling nuts forums , fire safety forums , metal balls forums , sales promotion forums , wooden bird houses forums , credit interest rate forums , credit facilities forums , college loan consolidation forums , cheap car insurance forums , cement mixer forums , car audio forums , beige marble forums , aluminum coil forums , advertising sign forums , how do i get out of debt forums , heat pump forums , health insurance virginia forums , grinding media forums , grain sheet forums , gold rings forums , glass tile forums , glass door handles forums , floor hinges forums , engineered floors forums , discover credit card forums , digital photo frame forums , curtain fabric forums , culture stone forums , credit usa forums , red monkey forums , mp4 player forums , marble tile forums , low noise forums , led lights forums , wood floor forums , wireless credit card forums , wall bracket forums , va loan rate forums , type of credit forums , tropical furniture forums , tiffany lamp forums , steel sheet forums , stainless steel tube forums , safe auto insurance forums , rubber mat forums , rolling shutters forums ,



You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You can edit your posts in this forum
You can delete your posts in this forum
You can vote in polls in this forum