Do you think it is fair that he did not win because Smoke forced him go to the bottom?l mean really, he should have won, and l do not care about the rules. l love it when other drivers win asides from the Chase contenders.
l just rushed the question. So l spelled Regan wrong.
l just rushed the question. So l spelled Regan wrong.

In my mind he won. He is one of 4 drivers l root For and and he won his first race. l do not care what others say that 01 car won the race! DE l iwas the team to Beat!

Ragan should have been the one doing the burnouts. l learned a long time ago about NASCAR rule making decisions. l am glad to see others are finally noticing it too.

He clearly went below the yellow line and did not get forced down.SMOKE wins

l personally dont think that he won. l think that what he did was against the rules. Tony may have pushed him below the line but he was allowed back up, and he should have fallen in behind Tony.

However, what l dont think is fair is that they placed him in 18th instead of second.
http://nascar.com/races/cup/2008/30/data/results_unofficial.html

Regan won that race

My opinion is now he is only two wins short of catching Elliott.

Like Stinky and Regan himself said, '' l should be the one out there doing burnouts.''

And now he finishes 18th for being forced below the Yellow Line. l bet you NASCAR Just alot of fans and respect for that, they definitely lost my respect.

l think he should've won the race today.
And l also am getting pretty annoyed with people who spell his name Ragan.(not you)


David Ragan
Regan Smith

l will probably get shot for my answer, but l agree. l think Regan won that race. Tony pushed him below the line and he came back in front of Stewart. Even the announcers said it was fair. But me thinks NASCAR was too afraid of the butt whooping Tony was ready to dish out! hahahahahahahahaha

He should have won. He is a talented driver!

He won fair and square, not his fault that he was forced below the yellow line.

He did win the race and NASCAR is too prideful to reverse their decision and admit that Stewart forced Regan below the line. l normally do not dispute finishes but this in an exception to the rule for me. Congrats to Regan for his first win even though it wo not make it into the books.

total crap. regan should have won that race and NASCAR gives him an 18th place when it should have been a win. Unbelievable. Absolutely unbelieveable.

smoke was holding his position & simply blocked. unless nascar determines that smoke pushed him down illegally, which is true only if regan had his nose far enough in there - & he did not - then smoke did nothing wrong. he did move back over enough to let regan back up & give him a chance to get back on track to try to make the pass. regan stayed below the line to complete the pass & never tried to give it back, so smoke wins.

the odd part is not that portion of the disagreement, but l know good & well l heard the commentators talking about going below the line on the last lap being ok during the truck race. if that is the case, then regan did nothing wrong. that is what he was arguing

l thank he should of won the race it was not fair what Tony did to him

He should be celebrating his first win right now.